A Sierpinski number is an odd number $k$ such that $k2^n+1$ takes only composite values. In 1962, Selfridge proved that $78557$ is a Sierpinski number. It remains the smallest known such number.
How was $78557$ originally suspected to be a candidate for proving this property? The year 1962 lies at the dawn of the age where some computer-based search might have been possible, but I would be surprised if that were the case.