The question is:
A circle has the equation ${(x - 3)^2 + (y + 9)^2 = 144}$. A smaller concentric circle has a radius one-third that of the larger one. Find the equation of the smaller circle.
So I would have thought that the radius of the smaller circle would be $\frac {144}{3} = 48$
But the answer to the question is $(x - 3)^2 + (y + 9)^2 = 16$
Which is one third of $\sqrt{144}$, i.e $12$.
Why is it not a third of $144$?