1

I am trying to solve this through differential equation but the results seems different from calculating with real numbers. the problem is simple

The radius of a circle is growing at the rate of $d$ units/sec, its initial radius is $R$, find the rate of increase of its area. The question is transcribed into the simple differential equation:

$Area= \pi.R^2$

$dA/dt = 2.\pi.R.dR/dt$

With an example say the initial radius is 4 units and the rate of increase is 0.5 units/sec:

$dA/dt = 2.\pi.4.(0.5) = 4.\pi$

However when I substitute real values

$Area (4) = \pi.4^2 = 16.\pi$

$Area (4.5) = \pi.(4.5)^2 = (20.25).\pi$

$Diff = (20.25).\pi - 16.\pi = (4.25).\pi$

The difference between these two is $(4.25).\pi$ and the $4.\pi$ as I obtained earlier. Why this difference? Shouldn't it be exactly $4.\pi$ ? What am I missing?

Thanks vijay

Ted Shifrin
  • 115,160
Vijay
  • 13
  • In the 2nd case you have calculated the areas at initial and final time and obtained the difference between the areas. In the 1st case you have evaluated the rate of change of area. They are not the same. – StubbornAtom Oct 12 '16 at 17:38
  • Can you explain more on the difference? Shouldn't this rate of change in area be a useable figure to calculate increase in area between two points - assuming all is linear and a simple growth of this circle? – Vijay Oct 12 '16 at 17:47
  • Hint: $dA / dt$ is not a constant. It depends on $R$ thus on $t$. – dxiv Oct 12 '16 at 17:56
  • This just stems from my curiosity and not a real "problem" perse – Vijay Oct 12 '16 at 18:01
  • The way you do it to find $\frac{dA}{dt}=4\pi$ is fine. As the answer below points out, I think you need to look into the definition of derivative to clear your doubts. – StubbornAtom Oct 12 '16 at 18:05

2 Answers2

0

@Vijay 's comment is the key to understanding your problem.

The derivative is the rate of change. If you look back to the definition of the derivative you'll see that it says (more or less) that the value of the difference is approximately the product of the derivative (the rate of change) and the time (in your example, $1$ second).

$$ (20.25)\pi−16\pi = 4.25\pi \approx 4\pi \times 1 $$ That approximation is better for smaller time intervals. You can test that numerically.

Ethan Bolker
  • 95,224
  • 7
  • 108
  • 199
0

Remember....that calculus is useful only for small changes....ie the rate of change of a quantity is quite small as compared to the quantity itself...and u can check this out urself by plugging in larger and larger values of dR/dt and u would notice that the answer u get from calculus would start becoming highly inaccurate as compared to what u actually calculate by simply plugging in final and initial values. So remember that calculus can be used in such situations only when rate of change of a quantity is considerably small as compared to the quantity itself. Although there is no specific limit for its accuracy but a % change of roughly 3-4 % would give u a nearly accurate answer....however the smaller the rate of change....the more accurate the results obtained using calculus are.

SirXYZ
  • 920