What is the difference, if any, between $x \in {(1,3)}$ and $1<x<3$ . Is it right to assume that in the second case $'x'$ might lie anywhere in the interval, but the first case tells us that all the values in the parentheses "must" be possible for a number?
Asked
Active
Viewed 69 times
0
-
As far as I know, they are the same. I am not familiar with an interpretation where the endpoints "'must' be possible." – angryavian Jan 13 '17 at 02:41
1 Answers
1
$1 < x < 3$ and $x \in (1, 3)$ mean exactly the same thing: the open interval $(a, b)$ is by definition the set $\{x \mid a < x < b\}$ so the assertion $x \in (1, 3)$ is equivalent to the assertion $1 < x < 3$. Don't try to read too much into "elegant variations" of notation.
Rob Arthan
- 48,577
-
I mean, if I solve a problem and get $x \in {(1,3)}$ can I tick correct an option which says $x \in {(1,4)}$ ?Thanks. – Petra Jan 13 '17 at 03:14
-
-
Um, yes, but my teacher insists that while using parentheses notation we should always write the exact set. – Petra Jan 13 '17 at 03:30
-
I have no idea what your teacher could mean by that. It sounds like hogwash to me. – Rob Arthan Jan 13 '17 at 03:36