0

On cuttheknot.org, a proof is given that the focus-directrix definition implies the equation definition (i.e. that an ellipse is a planar curve with equation $\frac{x^2}{a^2}+\frac{y^2}{b^2}=1$).

The first line of the proof states

Let $e$ be the ratio of distances and choose the system of coordinates so that the focus and the related directrix be $E(−ae,0)$ and $x=-\frac{a}{e}$.

How this is possible, is not at all clear to me. How can we simply do this, if we do not know $a$?

(Link to the full proof, go to 4 implies 2).

Lundborg
  • 1,646
  • If you know the eccentricity, focus and directrix, then you can also easily determine where the vertex of the ellipse along its major axis lies, i.e., you can compute $a$. – amd Mar 27 '17 at 22:48
  • @amd how would I do that? – Lundborg Mar 28 '17 at 06:54

1 Answers1

2

Given a focus $F$, directrix $d$ and eccentricity $e\in(0,1)$, the center of the ellipse, and so the origin of the coordinate system posited in the proof, can be found without explicitly computing the semi-major axis length $a$.

focus/directrix ellipse

Let $D$ be the intersection of the directrix $d$ and the perpendicular through $F$. ($\overline{DF}$ is, of course, the major axis of the ellipse.) One vertex $A$ is between $F$ and $D$. By definition, $(A-F)=e(D-A)$, so $$A=\frac1{1+e}F+\frac e{1+e}D.\tag1$$ The focus $F$ is between this point and the opposite vertex $A'$. For this other vertex we have $(A'-F)=e(A'-D)$, therefore $$A'=\frac1{1-e}F-\frac e{1-e}D.\tag2$$ The center of the ellipse is just the midpoint $$C=\frac12(A+A')={1\over1-e^2}F-{e^2\over1-e^2}D.\tag3$$ The semi-major axis length $a=\frac12\|A-A'\|$, but once you place the origin at $C$ and align the $x$-axis with the major axis ($\overline{DF}$), $F$ and $D$ will automatically have the correct coordinates.

amd
  • 53,693