4

Suppose $a < 0 < b$. Then what is the result of:

$\sqrt{(a-b)^2} + \sqrt[6]{ b^6 } = ?$

I have a solution but I can't be sure if I did a mistake, because I usually do! My solution:

Call $a = -c$ for some $0 < c $. Then,

$=\sqrt{(-c-b)^2} + \sqrt[6]{ b^6 }$

$=\sqrt{(- (c+b))^2} + \sqrt[6]{ b^6 }$

$=\sqrt{(c+b)^2} + \sqrt[6]{ b^6 }$

$=(c+b) + b$

$= -a +2b$

FiveF
  • 43

2 Answers2

2

That seems good to me. You should be careful that $\sqrt{(c+b)^2} = |c + b|$. But as $c$ and $b$ are both positive, $|c + b| = c+ b$.

You can actually be more direct:

$\sqrt{(a-b)^2} + \sqrt[6]{ b^6 } = |a-b| + |b|$.

As $b > 0$ we know $|b| = b$. As $a < 0$ and $b > 0$ then then $a- b < a < 0$. So $|a-b| = b -a$

So $\sqrt{(a-b)^2} + \sqrt[6]{ b^6 } = |a-b| + |b| = b -a + b = -a + 2b$.

But your reasoning was just fine. But it may be worth stating, you replaced $a$ with $-c$ to make all variables positive.

.....

And just to be thorough:

$|a - b| + |b| = $

1)$ a - b + b=a$; if $b \ge 0$ and $a-b \ge 0$ i.e. if $b \ge 0$ and $a \ge b$, i.e if $0 \le b \le a$.

2) $a - b - b = a - 2b$; if $b \le 0$ and $a-b \ge 0$ i.e. if $b \le 0$ and $a \ge b$. (whether $a$ is bigger or small or equal to zero doesn't matter so long as $a \ge b$.

3)$b-a + b = -a + 2b$ if $b\ge0$ and $a-b \le 0$ i.e. if $a \le b$ and $b \ge 0$ (whether $a$ is bigger or smaller or equal to zero doesn't matter; Note; your problem was a subset of this case.)

4) $b-a - b = -a$ if $b\le 0$ and $a-b \le 0$ i.e. if $a \le b \le 0$.

(Note: Those four cases are not mutually exclusive. If $b=0$ then 1) $|a-b| + |b| = a$ and 2) $|a-b| + |b| = a-2b = a$ are compatible, as are 3) $|a-b| + |b| = -a + 2b = -a$ and 4) $|a -b| + |b| = -a$.)

(If $a-b = 0$ i.e. $a= b$ then 1) $|a-b| + |b| = a$ and 3) $|a-b| +|b| = -a + 2b = -a + 2a = a$ are compatible, as are 2) $|a-b| + |b|=a-2b = a-2a = -a$ and 4) |a-b|+|b| = -a$.

(if $a-b =0$ and $b=0$ then all four are compatible $|a-b| + |b| = 0 =a=-a = a-2b = -a + 2b$.)

fleablood
  • 124,253
1

i would write $$\sqrt{(a-b)^2}+\sqrt[6]{b^6}=\sqrt{(b-a)^2}+\sqrt[6]{b^6}=b-a+b$$ this is the same as you

  • 1
    I'd think it is very important to point out that $b - a > 0$ so $\sqrt{(b-a)^2}=b-a$. Otherwise it looks like you are trying to do a false proof. You know.... $2 = \sqrt{4} = \sqrt{(3-1)^2} = \sqrt{(1-3)^2} = 1-3 = -2$ so $2+2 = -2+2$ so $4 = 0$ QED sort of thing. – fleablood Nov 27 '17 at 18:36