5

Find all pairs $(m, n)$ of positive integers such that $$m(n + 1) + n(m − 1) = 2013$$

What I've done: I tried to make the problem simpler by $2mn+m-n$ and factoring it equals $(2m-1)(2n+1)$

Where do I go now?

QuantumPi
  • 323
  • 1
    Start by modifying "N/A". You must have some idea where to start. Where did you get this problem? What book or topic did this problem appear in? – Shubham Johri Dec 30 '20 at 16:50
  • It's AMSP sample admission test..... – QuantumPi Dec 30 '20 at 16:53
  • 1
    Your factoring is not correct in that it has an extra term of $-1$ that you need to compensate for on the other side. Once you do that, look at the terms on each side. You are on the right track. – Ross Millikan Dec 30 '20 at 16:57
  • 5
    Great. You get $(2m-1)(2n+1)=4mn+2m-2n-1=2(2013)-1=4025$. Now, $4025=5^2723$ has $12$ odd factors. Can you list them and find $m,n$? – Shubham Johri Dec 30 '20 at 17:02
  • 1
    "2mn+m−n and factoring it equals (2m−1)(2n+1)" No it doesn't. – fleablood Dec 31 '20 at 17:19

3 Answers3

4

You started OK but you didn't see how easy it is to solve for $m$. \begin{align*} &m(n + 1) + n(m − 1) = 2013\\ &\implies 2 m n + m - n - 2013 = 0\\ &\implies m(2 n + 1) = n + 2013\\ &\implies m = \frac{n + 2013}{2 n + 1}\quad \land\quad 2 n + 1\ne0 \end{align*} Since $2n$ is always even, adding or subtracting $1$ from it will never yield zero so $n\in\mathbb{N}$ but not all values of $n$ will yield integers for $m$.

For $\quad 0\le n\le 2100\quad $ there are $11$ integer pairs $(m,n)$ and these appear to be the only solutions, according the descending-m and ascending-n pattern seen here.

$$ (403,2)\quad (288,3)\quad (88,11)\quad (81,12)\quad (58,17)\quad (18,57)\\ (13,80)\quad (12,87)\quad (4,287)\quad (3,402)\quad (1,2012)\quad $$

poetasis
  • 6,338
2

We have $$2mn+m-n=2013\implies4mn+2m-2n-1=4025$$ $$\implies(2m-1)(2n+1)=4025=5^2\times7\times23=1^0\times5^2\times7^1\times23^1$$ Hence there are $1\times3\times2\times2 =12$ factors that each bracket could correspond to so you have to check one bracket for each factor of $4025$, and the other bracket for each corresponding factor as you go along.

For example letting $$2m-1=1, ~~2n+1=4025$$ yields $m=1,~n=2012$ and so on for all the other pairs of factors. Note, you don't have to look for values of $m$ and $n$ for $2n+1=1$ as that would result in a negative value for $n$ which isn't allowed by the question.

If you don't understand something, or you need any more help, please don't hesitate to ask :)

1

If you've gotten $m(n+1) + n(m-1)= 2mn + m -n$

And $(2m-1)(2n+1) = 4mn +2m - 2n - 1$ so your factoring is not correct.

However if $m(n+1) + n(m-1) = 2mn + m -n = 2013$ then

$(2m-1)(2n+1) = 4mn + 2m -2n - 1 = 2(2mn + m -n) - 1 = 2*2013 - 1 = 4025$.

So now it's a matter of prime factoring $4025$.

Clearly $25|4025$ so $4025 = 161*5^2$ and $161=7*23$ so $4025 = 5^2*7*23$ and so

$(2m-1)(2n + 1) = 5^2 *7*23$ so you have the following problems to solve.

If you break $4025= 5^2*7*23$ into two factors, $4025 = A*B$ you will be get several ($24$) sets of equations to solve and several ($24$) pairs of solutions..

$2m-1 = A$ and $2n+1 = B$ so $m = \frac {A+1}2$ and $n = \frac {B-1}2$.

Where $(A,B) = $

$(1, 4025)$

$(5, 805)$

$(7, 575)$

$(23, 175)$

$(25, 161)$

$(35, 115)$,

..... etc..... (Don't forget the reverse pairs $A = 4025$ and $B=1$ and $A=805$ and $B = 5$ as well as $A=1; B=4025$ and $A=5;B=805$)....

fleablood
  • 124,253