1

Let $X$ be the set of all nonempty compact nowhere dense subsets of the real line. Is there a theorem that describes the form of the elements of $X$?

Context

For open subsets of the line, such a result is well-known: every open set is the disjoint union of open intervals. But compact sets can be substantially more complicated.

Paul
  • 20,553

2 Answers2

5

Up to homeomorphism the basic ones are homeomorphic copies of the ordinal space $\alpha+1$ for each $\alpha<\omega_1$, and Cantor sets. Of course $X$ is also closed under finite unions.

Of course a space homeomorphic to one of the countable compact ordinal space can be embedded in a non-obvious way. For example, $\omega^2+1$ can be embedded as follows:

$$f:\omega^2+1\to\Bbb R:\begin{cases} \omega\cdot n\mapsto\frac1{2^n}\\\\ \omega\cdot n+k\mapsto\frac1{2^{n+1}}-\frac1{2^{n+2+k}},&\text{if }k>0\\\\ \omega^2\mapsto 0\;. \end{cases}$$

The resulting set of reals looks schematically like this in its order in $\Bbb R$:

$$\bullet\dots\longrightarrow\bullet\longrightarrow\bullet\longrightarrow\bullet\longrightarrow\bullet\longrightarrow\bullet\bullet$$

The bullets ($\bullet$) from right to left are $f(\omega\cdot0),f(\omega\cdot 1),f(\omega\cdot2),\ldots,f(\omega^2)$. This is rather different from our usual picture of $\omega^2+1$ in its natural (ordinal) order.

Brian M. Scott
  • 616,228
1

It is the Mazurkiewicz–Sierpiński theorem combined with the fact that every compact perfect metric space contains a copy of the Cantor set. So in your case, the Mazurkiewicz–Sierpiński theorem applies and all countable, successor ordinals exhaust the homeomorphism type of non-empty compact nowhere-dense subsets of the real line. (All countable ordinals embed into $[0,1]$.)

Stefan Mazurkiewicz and Wacław Sierpiński, Contribution à la topologie des ensembles dénombrables, Fundamenta Mathematicae 1 (1920), 17–27.

It is noteworthy that this theorem appeared in the very first volume of Fundamenta Mathematicae.

Tomasz Kania
  • 16,361