To prove:the identity given above where $ a, b $ are vectors, $ B $ is the unit bivector in the $ a\wedge b $ plane and $\theta $ is the angle between $ a$ and $ b$. (From "Geometric Algebra for Physicists" by Doran and Lasenby).
Expanding the L.H.S i get $$ \frac{1+b.a}{|a+b|} - \frac{|a\wedge b|}{|a+b|}B $$
The R.H.S gives me by definition, $$ \cos(\theta/2) - \sin(\theta/2)B $$
Using grade projection, we should have
$$ \frac{1+b.a}{|a+b|} = \cos(\theta/2) $$
and
$$ \frac{|b\wedge a|}{|a+b|} = \sin(\theta/2) $$
But i can't think of an easy way to prove either. I am trying to prove it using geometry and the rules of GA, rather than trigonometry.
- 195
- 1
- 9
-
Please check theta=0 and a=b. can this be true for any a, b pair? – ahala Jul 15 '13 at 04:02
-
For theta = 0 the plane of rotation is not defined anyway – user997712 Jul 18 '13 at 07:35
1 Answers
Remember that a rotation can be performed through a composition of two reflections. Let $c$ be the vector in the $a \wedge b$ plane that has an angle $\theta/2$ with both $a$ and $b$. Then a rotation that would rotate $a$ to $b$ can be seen as
$$\underline R(s) = \hat c \hat a s \hat a \hat c$$
for any vector $s$. (Here, we're choosing trivially to reflect over $a$ and then reflect over the angle bisector.)
The question then becomes how we can compute the vector $c$ that bisects that angle. In fact, $c = \hat a + \hat b$ does this nicely (not well defined if $\hat b = - \hat a$, but then the plane is not well-defined anyway). Then $\hat c = (\hat a + \hat b)/|\hat a + \hat b|$ and we get the resulting rotor to be
$$R = \hat c \hat a = \frac{\hat a \hat a + \hat b \hat a}{|\hat a + \hat b|}$$
which takes the form you want. It is, however, not immediately clear to me how to generalize the problem to using non-unit vectors. This argument that $c$ is the right vector to reflect over doesn't work if you don't use unit vectors.
- 19,902
-
Upon a careful reading of the text, i think $ a $ and $ b $ are meant as unit vectors, although it is not explicitly stated in the question. Thanks for laying out the geometric picture. – user997712 Jul 18 '13 at 07:33