6

enter image description here

Triangle $ABC$ has a right angle at $C$, and $AC=BC= 1$. Let $I$ be the incenter of triangle $ABC$. Let $D$, $E$, and $F$ be the midpoints of $AI$, $BI$, and $CI$, respectively. Furthermore, let $J$ be the intersection of $AE$ and $BD$, $K$ be the intersection of $BF$ and $CE$, and $L$ be the intersection of $CD$ and $AF$.

Find the area of hexagon $DJEKFL$.

Write your answer in the form $a/b$, where $a$ and $b$ are positive integers and $\gcd(a, b) = 1$.​

Answer of this problem is $1/6$.


But my answer is 3/8.

Here's My approach

Let $M$ be the midpoint of $AB$. Since triangle $ABC$ is isosceles, $M$ is also the midpoint of $CI$. Hence, $DM$ is a median of triangle $ADI$, and $EF$ is a median of triangle $BDI$. Therefore, by the triangle median property, $DM = 1/2 AD$ and $EF = 1/2 BD$.

Since $I$ is the incenter of triangle $ABC$, we have angle $AIC = \angle BIC = 90 + \angle C/2$. Thus, $\angle AID = 180 - \angle AIC = 90 - \angle C/2$. Similarly, $\angle BID = 90 - \angle C/2$.

Therefore, triangles $AID$ and $BID$ are similar, and we have $AD/BD = AI/BI = \sin(B/2)/\sin(A/2) = \cos(C/2)/\sin(A/2)$. Since triangle $ABC$ is isosceles, we have $\angle BAC = 90 - \angle C/2$. Thus, $\sin(A/2) = \cos(BAC/2) = \cos((90 - \angle C/2)/2) = \sin(C/4)/\sqrt2$.

Therefore, $AD/BD = \cos(C/2)/(\sin(C/4) \sqrt2)$. It follows that $DM/EF = (1/2 AD)/(1/2 BD) = \cos(C/2)/\sin(C/4) \sqrt2$.

By the angle bisector theorem, we have $AE/BE = AC/BC = 1$. Thus, $J$ is the midpoint of $AE$, and $K$ is the midpoint of $BF$. Therefore, the line segments $DJ$ and $EK$ divide triangle $DEF$ into three triangles, each of which is similar to triangle $BDI$.
The ratio of the area of triangle $DJK$ to the area of triangle $DEF$ is $(DJ/EJ)^2 = (EK/BK)^2 = (BD/2EF)^2 = (2 \cos(C/2)/\sin(C/4))^2 = 4 \cos^2(C/2)/\sin^2(C/4)$.

The ratio of the area of triangle $DJL$ to the area of triangle $DEF$ is $(DJ/DL)^2 = (1/2 DM/DF)^2 = (\cos(C/2)/\sin(C/4) \sqrt2/EF)^2 = 2 \cos^2(C/2)/\sin^2(C/4)$.

The ratio of the area of triangle $EKL$ to the area of triangle $DEF$ is $(EK/EL)^2 = (1/2 EF/EM)^2 = (1/2 EF/CI)^2 = (1/2 EF/(2EF/\cos(C/2)))^2 = 4 \cos^2(C/2)$.

Therefore, the area of hexagon $DJEKFL$ is the difference between the area of triangle $DEF$ and the sum of the areas of triangles $DJK$, $DJL$, and $EKL$. Hence,

$Area(DJEKFL) = (1/2) EF^2 (1 - 4 \cos^2(C/2)/\sin^2(C/4) - 2 \cos^2(C/2)/\sin^2(C/4) - 4 \cos^2(C/2))$.

Substituting $\cos(C/2) = \sqrt{1 - \sin^2(C/2)}$ and $\sin(C/2) = 1/\sqrt{1 + \cot^2(C/2)}$, we obtain

$Area(DJEKFL) = (1/4) (1 - \sin^2(C/4)) (1 + \cos(C/2) - \cos^2(C/2) - 2 \cos^4(C/2))$.

Simplifying, we obtain $Area(DJEKFL) = (1/4) (1 - (1 - \cos(C/2))/(2\sin(C/4))) (2 \cos^4(C/2) - \cos^3(C/2) - \cos^2(C/2) - \cos(C/2) + 1)$.

Simplifying, we obtain

$Area(DJEKFL) = (1/16) (2\sin(C/4) + \cos(C/2) - 1) (2 \cos^4(C/2) - \cos^3(C/2) - \cos^2(C/2) - \cos(C/2) + 1)$.

Now, we can use the identity $\cos(2x) = 2\cos^2(x) - 1$ to express $\cos^4(C/2)$ in terms of $\cos(2C)$:

$\cos^4(C/2) = (1/4) (2\cos^2(C/2) - 1)^2 = (1/4) (2\cos^2(C) - 3)^2 = (1/4) (\cos^2(C) - 4\cos^2(C) + 4) = (3/4) - (1/4) \cos^2(C)$.

Similarly, we can use the identity $\cos(3x) = 4\cos^3(x) - 3\cos(x)$ to express $\cos^3(C/2)$ and $\cos^2(C/2)$ in terms of $\cos(C)$:

$\cos^3(C/2) = (1/2) \cos(C/2) (1 + \cos(C)) = (1/2) \sqrt{1 - \sin^2(C/2)} (1 + \cos(C))$,

$\cos^2(C/2) = 1 - \sin^2(C/2) = \cos^2(C/2) - \sin^2(C/2) = \cos(C) - \sin^2(C/2)$. Substituting these expressions into the formula for the area of hexagon $DJEKFL$ and simplifying, we obtain

$Area(DJEKFL) = (3/16) (2\sin(C/4) + \cos(C/2) - 1) (1 - \cos(C) - \cos^2(C/2) - \cos(C/2) + 1)$.

Simplifying further, we obtain

$Area(DJEKFL) = (3/16) (2\sin(C/4) + \cos(C/2) - 1) (\sin^2(C/2) - \cos(C/2) - \cos(C) + 1)$.

Finally, we can use the half-angle identity again to express $\sin^2(C/2)$ in terms of $\cos(C/2)$:

$\sin^2(C/2) = (1 - \cos(C))/2$.

Substituting this into the formula for the area of hexagon $DJEKFL$ and simplifying, we obtain

$Area(DJEKFL) = (3/32) (\cos(C/2) - 2(8\cos^4(C/4) - 8\cos^2(C/4) + 1) + 2(2\cos^2(C/4) - 1) + 1)$.

Simplifying further, we obtain

$Area(DJEKFL) = (3/8) \cos^4(C/4) - (9/8) \cos^2(C/4) + (1/4)$.

Therefore, the area of hexagon $DJEKFL$ is $(3 \cos^4(C/4) - 9 \cos^2(C/4) + 2)/8$. To write this in the form $a/b$, we can multiply the numerator and denominator by $8$ to obtain

$Area(DJEKFL) = (3 \cos^4(C/4) - 9 \cos^2(C/4) + 2)/8 = (3 \cos^4(C/4) - 9 \cos^2(C/4) + 2)/(2^3) = 3/8 * (\cos^4(C/4) - 3 \cos^2(C/4) + 2/3)$.

Since $\gcd(3, 8) = 1$, the answer is $3/8 * (\cos^4(C/4) - 3 \cos^2(C/4) + 2/3)$.

ACB
  • 3,713
Priyanshu
  • 125

1 Answers1

7

First of all, the fact that $I$ is the incenter of triangle $ABC$ plays no role. $I$ could be any interior point in $ABC$, as can be checked on this Geogebra animation (whatever the position of point I, the area $d$ remains the same, equal to $\frac16$ ; one can also move points $A,B,C$).

enter image description here

Let [...] denote the area.

Clearly, as $[ABC]=\frac12$, we just have to prove that

$$[LFKEJD]=\frac13[ABC].$$

Let us dissect the hexagon into 3 quadrilaterals : $DIEJ, \ IFKE, \ DLFI$.

In triangle $ABI$, as $J$ is its centroid, $[DIEJ]=\frac13[ABI]$ (see explanation below).

For a similar reason,

  • $[IFKE]=\frac13[ICB]$.

  • $[DLFI]=\frac13[ACI]$.

Summing up these relationships, we indeed obtain :

$$[DLFKEJ]=\frac13[ABC].$$


Explanation of the 'one-third' property used three times above:

Consider a general triangle $PQR$ ; let $P'Q'R'$ be its mid-triangle and $G$ its centroid. See animated figure below :

enter image description here

As $[PQ'R']=[P'Q'R']=\frac14[PQR]$ :

$$[PR'GQ']=[PR'Q']+[R'GQ']=\frac14[PQR]+\frac13\frac14[PQR]=$$

$$[PR'GQ']=(\frac14+\frac{1}{12})[PQR]=\frac13[PQR]$$

as desired.

Jean Marie
  • 81,803