1

prismoid container

Imagine a prismoid container like the one pictured. I have poured water into it and I know all values of the resulting water prismoid - I know its volume, it's height, the areas of its bases, the area of the midsection and the angles of its sides.

Now I want to pour in more water for it to reach a certain volume. How much higher should the water surface (or top base) be to reach that volume?

I have really been racking my brain to make a working formula but cannot. Can any genius help me?

Hosam Hajeer
  • 21,978
morkfromork
  • 11

2 Answers2

1

Let the top rectangular face have sides $A$ and $b$ and the bottom rectangular face have sides $a$ and $B$, such that $A$ and $a$ are parallel, $|A| > |a|$, and similar for the other ones.

Then consider the Stott contracted "prismatoid" with top "rectangle" with sides $C$ with length $|C|=|A|-|a|$ and $d$ with length $|d|=|b|-|b|=0$ and bottom "rectangle" with sides $c$ of length $|c|=|a|-|a|=0$ and $D$ of length $|D|=|B|-|b|$. Obviously it still has the same height and the lacing face planes all would be just shifted copies of the former, just that these lacing faces now become triangles only, whereas the top and bottom faces degenerate into line segments (of already provided lengths $C$ and $D$ respectively).

Thus you have reduced your problem in finding the height of a simplex (between an opposite pair of edges). That simplex further would be a sphenoid (having two opposite sides at orthogonal directions). But without any further informations no more can be said here. However, your problem thus has been reduced to a simple elementary geometric task.

--- rk

Dr. Richard Klitzing
  • 4,241
  • Could you give some reference for the "Stott contracted prismoid" ? – Jean Marie Jan 05 '24 at 18:51
  • A. Boole Stott, "Geometrical deduction of semiregular from regular polytopes and space fillings", Verhandlingen der koninklijke Akademie van Wetenschappen, eerste Sectie, Deel XI (Amsterdam, published 1913 – but submitted already 1910). - Therein she introduces expansion and contraction operations, then however being applied to regular polytopes. My above application is just direct, in fact wrt. the rectangular subsymmetry perpendicular to the height axis. – Dr. Richard Klitzing Jan 06 '24 at 21:20
  • Richard Klitzling Thank you very much. Now I remember the story : (if I am right) the woman who made so nice drawings of polytopes even in dimension $> 3$... connected to the "great" Boole. – Jean Marie Jan 06 '24 at 21:46
1

Split the polyhedron along the red lines into two "roof shaped" polyhedra $P_1=GHABCD$ and $P_2=ADEFGH$ with notations present in the figure below.

Let us denote by $h$ the present height of water, and $h_m$ the maximal height ; the volume of $P_1,P_2$ will be resp.

$$V_1=ah^3, \ \ \ V_2=b(h_m-h)^3$$

for certain constants $a, \ b$. Do you see why ? (use a homothety argument).

With these formulas, using the data you have, you should find out the $\Delta h$ you are looking for.

enter image description here

Jean Marie
  • 81,803